According to police, Kingston, who had a three-year relationship with Annese , brought a "large knife" to the home and confronted Annese and Hutchinson. Colin Kingston then turned the knife on himself suffering fatal self inflicted stab wounds.

Matthew Hutchinson's gear at the Geneseo Fire Department where he served as a volunteer firefighter.

Unlike Barnes' story, where signs of abuse were present during the relationship, the story of Kelsey Annese, or at least what is known of it, was seemingly different.

While Barnes had feared for her life at points throughout her relationship, friends of Annese said the more than three years that she spent dating Kingston seemed nothing short of healthy.

I didn't even hear anything, there wasn't any yelling, but she did say that he was pretty upset," said Mc Kenna. I think she was just at a different point in her life where that wasn't what she wanted anymore.

She had mentioned wanting to go away to New York City to teach.

Knight-Hollis is currently held without bail in Wayne County jail, and awaiting his trial date.

17, Mc Kenna was asleep in a hotel with her parents who had come in for the weekend from Long Island, Cohan was in bed at her home in Rochester, and Sobieraski had just woken up to her phone vibrating, which she answered from her room in Buffalo. "No one in the house heard a thing, so we have no idea how things played out,” said Sobieraski, referring to other housemates who were there at the time of the murders. While the exact details of that night and why Kingston chose to do what he did, remain unknown, one thing that's been made evident is that the reach of dating violence extends far beyond what one might assume as the traditional definition."Nothing that I ever saw would have made me think that something like this would ever happen," said Mc Kenna. Waiting for the doors to open for the remembrance ceremony in the Kuhl Gymnasium of the SUNY Geneseo campus for Kelsey Annese, 21, of Webster and Matthew Hutchinson, 24, of North Vancouver, British Columbia, who were stabbed to death by former student Colin Kingston.Matthew Hutchinson was one of three people in their early 20s were found dead Sunday morning in an off-campus home near the SUNY Geneseo campus.A photo of Matthew Hutchinson appears on a christmas card he was given by members of the Geneseo Fire Department where he served as a volunteer firefighter.A Canadian flag was brought down to the Geneseo Fire Department by teammates of Matthew Hutchinson's hockey team.According to police, Kingston, who had a three-year relationship with Annese , brought a "large knife" to the home and confronted Annese and Hutchinson. Colin Kingston then turned the knife on himself suffering fatal self inflicted stab wounds. where three people in their early 20s were found dead Sunday morning in an off-campus home near the SUNY Geneseo campus.